Chapter 5.
“A myth is a public dream, and a dream is a private myth.” — Joseph Campbell
The Instinct for Agency
From the dawn of human consciousness, we have sought to understand the unseen forces shaping our world. While early observations readily connected a hurtling rock with a human thrower, this instinct to find agency extends beyond the tangible. It leads us to seek meaning in the mysterious. It was in these realms of the unknown that the earliest narratives and forms of faith likely took root.
This instinct is rooted in a fundamental evolutionary mechanism. Cognitive scientists call this innate human bias Agenticity. It is the tendency to infer the existence of deliberate, conscious movers behind events in our environment. Specifically, our brains employ a Hyperactive Agency Detection Device (HADD). This is not a cognitive flaw but a powerful neurological survival tool. In the ancestral environment, the cost of failing to detect a real agent was potentially fatal. The cost of detecting a false agent was low. HADD is highly effective because it is evolutionarily designed to constantly err on the side of caution.
Evolutionary Roots of Belief
This over-sensitivity to intention is precisely what gives rise to supernatural belief. The HADD mechanism ensures that ambiguous natural phenomena are involuntarily over-attributed to intention. A sudden rustle in the grass, a devastating storm or the predictable movement of the sun are examples. It is this deeply hardwired tendency to look for a ‘who’ behind the ‘what’ that first gave birth to the earliest supernatural agents.
While this cognitive trait explains what can give rise to faith, it is crucial to note that understanding the evolutionary mechanism of belief does not equate to a refutation of the object of belief. The HADD hypothesis explains why the human mind is predisposed to perceive agency, whether or not it is present. But it operates entirely within the measurable realm of psychology and biology. It is therefore inherently silent on the metaphysical truth of whether or not genuine, non-material agents exist. In this sense, scientific inquiry provides a powerful explanation for our religious impulse. It does not provide a judgement on the ultimate reality of the divine. This chapter explores the human capacity for faith. The validity of its ultimate claims remains a separate question.
Ritual and Social Cohesion
Early forms of faith were deeply intertwined with trance experiences. These were not formal religions with gods or moral codes. They were an engagement with a spirit world accessible through altered states of consciousness. These were often induced by communal trance dances. These mystical experiences triggered the release of endorphins. They played a crucial role in group bonding and social cohesion. As human group sizes increased, these shared ritualistic experiences provided a new mechanism for creating a sense of community. This deep historical rooting of religion in social cohesion may also contribute to why, even as overt religious adherence declines, the belief in belief can persist.
The human quest for agency grew into the diverse and complex systems we know as faith. These were a natural and deeply human response to the fundamental quest for meaning and understanding in a world that often seemed chaotic. A key aspect of this early myth-making was the personification of physical phenomena. Powerful forces of nature were attributed to the actions and intentions of deities. The sun was perceived as having agency. It rose and set. It brought warmth or scorched. Early humans probably concluded that it was a conscious entity. It possessed will and emotion. This anthropomorphism made the vast and impersonal forces of nature more understandable.
Design, Purpose, and Mythic Archetypes
This initial perception of agency naturally developed into a teleological bias. Complex natural objects are seen as being deliberately designed for a purpose. For example, even adults often instinctively believe that a mountain must have been ‘made for something.’ This is despite it being merely the result of aimless geological forces. This hardwired perception of design and purpose ultimately fuels the creation of structured narratives. Gods and goddesses are given motives and intentions to explain the ‘design’ of the cosmos.
As we observe the pantheons of early cultures around the globe, a remarkable consistency emerges. The sky and its dramatic weather were often associated with a powerful masculine deity. The earth was frequently personified as a nurturing maternal goddess. This universality across diverse cultures strongly underlines that these early myths were not malicious fabrications. Instead, they likely arose from a shared human experience of trying to understand and navigate a complex world. These figures often point towards universal archetypes of authority and nurture. They reflect our own inner landscapes projected onto the external world. The remarkable recurrence of mythic themes like the hero’s journey or the flood myth across vastly different cultures provides further evidence of an overarching unity in the human experience.
From Supplication to Sacred Text
This shared human experience naturally extended to how early humans engaged with these perceived agencies. The act of asking for divine intervention mirrored earnest supplications to other humans. The practice of offerings and sacrifice evolved from the human habit of giving gifts for favour. The respect shown to human leaders was mirrored in reverence for sacred spaces. The comfort found in communal gatherings gave rise to ceremonies and festivals. The transition from oral tradition to written texts naturally imbued these foundational stories with an even greater sense of permanence and authority. The act of writing down these myths and teachings fixed them in a tangible form. This made them sacred objects. It strengthened the power of religious institutions and the individuals who became their custodians.
This dedicated intellectual endeavour focused on fundamental questions of existence and meaning. It gradually developed into what we now recognise as philosophy. Early mythologies served as initial frameworks for understanding the cosmos and human existence. Philosophy offered a more reasoned approach to the same deep-seated yearning for meaning.
The Power and Peril of Conviction
Irrespective of individual belief or the absence thereof, one cannot help but marvel at the extraordinary human capacity that is unleashed when motivated by an underlying conviction in a shared purpose. This power of belief provides individuals and communities with a sense of meaning. It provides a driving force that extends beyond the tangible.
It would be an oversight not to acknowledge faith’s unfortunate capacity for destruction. History offers countless examples where religious fervour has been twisted to justify violence, oppression and intolerance. Dogmatic adherence to belief can actively resist the acceptance of contrary realities. This hinders progress.
Ethical Frameworks and Shared Aspirations
Faith and the philosophical traditions that often spring from it have provided humanity with ethical frameworks. They have provided a compelling vision of our potential for good. Many faiths emphasise compassion, justice and the inherent value of every individual. They inspire acts of altruism and the pursuit of social betterment.
In examining the world’s religions, a commonality emerges. All faiths seek to cultivate a response to Harm and Care. They advocate for Fairness and Reciprocity. They foster Loyalty. They establish Authority. They address Purity and Sanctity. While the expressions of these values differ, the underlying moral compass points in the same direction. This highlights our shared human aspiration for a good and meaningful life.
It is a testament to the fundamental human needs that faith-based structures address that secular movements have emerged. These consciously or unconsciously mirror some of their key aspects. The Sunday Assembly is a global, secular community movement. It aims to provide a sense of community, belonging and inspiration for non-religious individuals. These individuals miss the social and spiritual aspects of church without the religious content. The emergence and growth of movements like the Sunday Assembly underscore the enduring human need for community, shared values and a sense of purpose. This is even in the absence of traditional religious frameworks. This observation lends further credence to the ‘belief in belief’ concept. It suggests that even as overt religious belief declines, the human inclination to value the functions and forms associated with religion remains powerful. Be it community, ritual or shared narrative, the instinct remains.
Next Chapter: Sex and Celibacy: Instruments of Power
Bibliography
Barrett, Justin L. Why Would Anyone Believe in God? Oxford University Press. 2004
Boyer, Pascal. Religion Explained: The Evolutionary Origins of Religious Thought. Basic Books. 2001
Campbell, Joseph. The Hero with a Thousand Faces. Princeton University Press. 2008
Campbell, Joseph. The Inner Reaches of Outer Space: Metaphor as Myth and as Religion. Harper Perennial. 2002
Campbell, Joseph. The Masks of God, Vol. 1: Primitive Mythology. Viking Penguin. 1976
Dennett, Daniel C. Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon. Viking. 2006
Dunbar, Robin I. M. How Religion Evolved: And Why It Endures. Pelican Books. 2023
Dunbar, Robin I. M. Human Evolution: A Pelican Introduction. Pelican Books. 2014
Guthrie, Stewart. Faces in the Clouds: A New Theory of Religion. Oxford University Press. 1993
Haidt, Jonathan. The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion. Vintage. 2013
Jung, Carl G. The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious. Princeton University Press. 1968